The short answer depends on where each employee works, not where you're headquartered
The question usually arrives in one of three ways. A labor inspector sends a request. A former employee files an overtime claim. Or a finance team expanding into a new country discovers that "we trust our people" isn't a timekeeping policy. In every case the answer turns on the employee's work location, not your head office or your payroll currency.
Working time recording requirements fall into three broad groups:
- Universal daily recording. Every employee's start and end times are logged every day, salaried staff included. This is the direction across the EU, and national rules such as Spain's already work this way.
- Threshold or purpose-based recording. You keep records that prove compliance with specific limits: weekly maximums, night work, minimum wage, holiday. The UK and much of the Gulf work this way.
- Register-based recording for covered workers. You keep statutory attendance and overtime registers for defined categories of workers, with exemptions for managerial roles. India and Brazil follow this model, with very different enforcement intensity.
If you employ people in more than one group, the rule is simple. Build your time system to the strictest standard you face, then switch features off by country. Retrofitting after an inspection costs more than configuring up front.
Looking to streamline vendor RFP selection?
Access pre-negotiated tier discounts through our independent institutional network.
The EU court ruling and how Spain and Germany turned it into an obligation
The EU obligation traces back to one judgment. In May 2019, in CCOO v Deutsche Bank SAE (C-55/18), the Court of Justice of the European Union held that member states must require employers to set up an "objective, reliable and accessible" system for measuring each worker's daily working time. Without it, the court reasoned, nobody can verify that the Working Time Directive's limits (the 48-hour average week, daily and weekly rest, paid leave) are respected. A records duty covering only overtime wasn't enough.
The ruling binds member states, not employers directly. What you must do depends on how each country has legislated, and that varies.
Spain: strict, specific and enforced
Spain moved first. Since 2019, employers have had to keep a daily register (registro de jornada) of each employee's start and finish times, including part-time, salaried and remote staff. Records must be kept for four years and be available to employees, worker representatives and the Labor Inspectorate. Fines for breaches are set per infraction and can be significant. Reform proposals to require digital, tamper-resistant registers that inspectors can access remotely have been under discussion, so paper sign-in sheets and editable spreadsheets are a growing risk.
Germany: obligation first, detail later
Germany took a different route. In 2022 the Federal Labor Court ruled that the existing Occupational Safety and Health Act already obliges employers to record employees' working hours. Before that, the Working Hours Act required records only of time beyond eight hours a day. The duty applies now. What legislation is still settling is the format: electronic recording, deadlines for entries, and how much room collective agreements and trust-based working time (Vertrauensarbeitszeit) will get. Check the current statutory status with German counsel, but don't wait for it. Courts and works councils are already applying the obligation.
Elsewhere in the EU, countries such as Italy, Portugal and Greece impose recording duties of varying strictness, and a few still lean on older rules. Assume the trend runs toward universal, verifiable records.
How the UK, India, Brazil and the Gulf compare
Outside the EU, requirements tend to be tied to specific limits rather than a blanket daily log. The table gives the general position. Treat it as a map for a conversation with local counsel, not a substitute for one.
| Jurisdiction | Daily recording for all staff? | What must be recorded | Common exemptions | Typical retention |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| EU (Spain, Germany and most others) | Yes, or moving that way | Daily start and end times, total hours | Narrow; managing executives with real autonomy | Spain 4 years; varies elsewhere |
| UK | No | "Adequate records" showing compliance with the 48-hour limit, night work, opt-outs, minimum wage and holiday | Workers with autonomous working time; opt-out workers still need some records | Around 2 years for working time; longer for minimum wage records |
| India | For covered workers, yes | Attendance, hours, overtime and wage registers under labor codes and state shops and establishments laws | Managerial and supervisory staff in many cases | Set by rules and state law; electronic registers often allowed |
| Brazil | Yes, for larger establishments (a headcount threshold applies) | Entry and exit times (manual, mechanical or electronic, under Ministry rules) | Managers in positions of trust; some external and task-paid remote workers | Several years, in line with the labor claims limitation period |
| Gulf (UAE, Saudi Arabia, Qatar) | Not as a blanket rule | Hours and overtime, enough to prove compliance with daily and weekly limits and reduced Ramadan hours | Senior and managerial roles commonly excluded from overtime | Varies by country; keep for the employment period plus the claims window |
Two points matter more than the table suggests. In Brazil, if a covered employer can't produce time records in a labor claim, courts generally lean toward the employee's account of their hours. Missing records lose cases there. In India, the consolidated labor codes are folding many older registers into a smaller set, but state-level rules still differ, so a company with offices in Bengaluru and Pune may run two register formats during the transition.
Salaried, remote and senior staff: who is actually exempt
This is where most compliance gaps show up. Many employers assume a fixed salary, or working from home, takes someone out of scope. In most jurisdictions it doesn't.
Time recording for salaried employees is expected in Spain and Germany regardless of pay structure. Salary decides how overtime is paid. It doesn't decide whether hours are measured. The EU directive does allow derogations for workers whose working time isn't measured or predetermined, such as managing executives with autonomous decision-making power. Courts read that narrowly. A senior engineer with a manager's title who still works to deadlines set by someone else usually doesn't qualify.
Remote staff are covered on the same basis as office staff. In practice that means app- or browser-based clock-ins, not badge readers. Brazil offers a useful contrast: its telework rules distinguish employees paid by the hour, who fall under time control, from those paid by output or task, who may not.
Say a 60-person software company has 25 engineers in Madrid, 20 in Berlin, 10 in London and 5 in São Paulo (a hypothetical example). Every Madrid and Berlin employee needs daily records, including salaried leads. London needs records good enough to show 48-hour compliance and opt-outs. São Paulo may fall under the establishment-size threshold, so formal time control might not be mandatory, but records would still help defend an overtime claim. The simplest compliant setup is one tool, configured to the Spanish standard, rolled out to all 60.
What a time system must capture and keep to satisfy an inspector
Inspectors aren't looking for a brand. They want records that are objective, hard to alter after the fact, and quick to produce. At a minimum, your system should capture:
- Daily start and end times for each employee, plus breaks where local law requires them.
- An audit trail for edits: who changed an entry, when, and why. Silent overwrites are the most common red flag.
- Overtime calculated against local limits, with approvals attached.
- Employee access to their own records, which the EU ruling's "accessible" standard and Spanish rules point to.
- Exports by date range and employee, in a format you can hand over within days.
- Retention rules set per country, so you meet the longest relevant period for each workforce.
- Data-protection controls: no continuous GPS tracking or biometrics unless local law and employee consultation allow it. GDPR, Brazil's LGPD and India's data protection law can all apply to time data.
Red flags in vendor demos: managers can edit entries without a logged reason; data can't be exported without a support ticket; there's no country-level rules engine; or data residency is fixed to one region.
On cost, standalone time-tracking tools such as Clockify or Jibble, and the attendance modules inside HR suites such as Factorial, Personio, Sesame HR, Darwinbox or Keka, typically run from roughly $2 to $10 per employee per month. Those are typical 2026 market ranges that vary by contract, region and bundle, so confirm current pricing with each vendor. Expect to pay more for geofencing, hardware terminals, or systems certified for Brazilian requirements.
The decision rule: if you have staff in Spain, Germany or Brazil, put daily recording in place now and set it to the strictest standard you face. Before signing a contract, ask employment counsel in each country to confirm exemptions, retention periods and any works council or employee consultation steps.